For the last two and one-half days the Assembly has met in several
committees to consider the business before the Assembly. In the Committee
meetings the items were handled with care. Not everybody agreed on
everything. We would not expect them to. Issues from the situation in
Iraq, mission funding, abortion, procedures, changes in the Book of Order,
and celebrating the new church school curriculum were among those before
the committees. Most of the Committees completed their business by dinner
on Tuesday. This provided the Commissioners with an evening for recharging
their batteries for the plenary meeting running from Wednesday afternoon
through Saturday morning.
The Assembly moved with dispatch through the initial business before
the Assembly the first afternoon of reconvening in plenary session. By the
time they broke for dinner the Assembly was about two hours ahead of the
projected docket. (I would bet that by tomorrow evening that cushion will
have disappeared.) Actually, it is gone now that the dinner break if
completed due to an early recess for dinner.
This evening Erin and I hosted our delegation for dinner. It was a good
time of reflecting on the progress of the Assembly, telling some stories
on ourselves, and enjoying the fellowship of the table. Those at dinner
were our YAD, Tim King, our Commissioners Gary Lyon and Roy Tomb, Mary
Marks King, Erin and myself.
I thought for a while the Assembly was just going to breeze through the
reports of the committees with little debate. Then came the report of the
Evangelism and Higher Education Committee. One recommendation, in response
to an overture from the Presbytery of Inland Northwest, was to "…to direct
the General Assembly Council, Congregational Ministries Division, to
explore the appropriateness of recommending the Alpha Program as a
congregational resource for evangelism [and to supplement as necessary to
reflect the Reformed tradition and the Presbyterian Church (U.S.A.)].
It was interesting to note that the Assembly seemed willing to be more
eclectic in the source of evangelism resources.
After an extended debate the Assembly voted to affirm the decision of
the Assembly last year to move to Biennial Assemblies. The vote was not
over-whelming in the weight of the vote. The affirmation passed on a 56%
vote.
As was expected there were a series of substitute nominations of people
to serve on the General Assembly Permanent Judicial Commission.
Dissatisfaction with some of the recent decisions of the GAPJC brought
forth a concerted effort by some factions of the denomination to insure
the GAPJC will be peopled with those they feel will more accurately
reflect their views. Only one such proposed substitution was elected by
the Assembly.
With the decision to affirm the biennial meetings of the Assembly and
the adoption of a new formula for determining the number of Commissioners
the Youth Advisory Delegates rose up in dismay that the ration of YADs to
Commissioners would be reduced. The YADs were advocating an increase in
their number. It seemed to me that the "entitled generation" was whining.
Each presbytery will still get one YAD each, as it has been for many
years.
Concerns about significant social and missional issues came before the
Assembly through the Global Ministries Committee. Concerns ranged from the
Mid-east, to Cuba, to Taiwan. It was out of compassion for people in
desperate situations and how we can demonstrate the love and justice of
Jesus to them. The Assembly is deeply bogged down in these issues and
concerns. Any and all time ahead of docket which the Assembly enjoyed
yesterday is long gone (as I predicted).
Upon returning from dinner this evening (Thursday) the Assembly took up
the very controversial issue of late term abortion. The was a majority
report and a minority report. The two reports were very much the same with
a few significant differences. A Commissioner asked that the debate be
respectful and avoid emotionally graphic descriptions. The significant
difference in the two reports is a requirement of for "moral" counseling
to the mother prior to final decisions on a late term abortion. Both
reports maintain the proviso for an abortion in the case of rape, insect
or to protect the life of the mother. One Commissioner offered an
amendment to seek options which would provide for the life of both the
mother and fetus in the case where the mother’s life is endangered. The
Assembly voted, after a tired debate, not to substitute the minority
report for the main motion. The Assembly voted to adopt the main motion by
a 77% affirmative vote. The debate, even though tired was decorous and the
Commissioners felt good about how they handled this sensitive issue.
Moderator Susan is doing a very good job in the chair. She is very
careful and respectful of all commissioners. She has allowed the
Vice-moderator Easley more time moderating the Assembly than several past
Moderators have done.
I have been wonderfully pleased with the number of people to have said
to me, or to Erin in my hearing, how much they appreciate her writing and
her service on the Mission Initiative Steering Committee. People from
across the denomination know what we know. We are blessed to have Erin
serving with and among us. John Detterick, Executive Director of the
General Assembly Council, was one of many to comment about Erin’s wide
range of talents and gifts which are being used in the more inclusive
governing bodies.
Mary Marks King, our representative on the General Assembly Council, is
having an opportunity to see how the Assembly deals with various actions
she has encountered on the GAC. I imagine that sometimes she is pleased
and at others disappointed. It will be interesting to hear how the GAC
responds to many of the missional and programmatic decisions of the
Assembly.